Most articles comparing retirement in France and Spain are written from spreadsheets. This one is built on a real couple's experience.
One of my clients, an American who retired from New York this year, did something few people try: he and his wife moved to Spain and France at the same time. They have an apartment in San Sebastián and an old country house near Pau, about two hours away across the border. Within a few months they had registered with authorities, bought property, set up utilities, sorted health insurance and bought a car, in both countries.
The quick answer: in his experience, France was easier on paperwork and property buying, and Spain was easier on daily costs, setting up a phone line and getting help in person. For most American retirees, the bigger difference is tax: France's treaty with the US is unusually generous for retirement income, while Spain taxes most of it and varies a lot by region. Healthcare quality and cost of living were good in both, and much cheaper than New York.
Who this comparison is based on (and why that matters)
I've helped more than 100 people retire to Spain. Through Coming to Spain I connected this client with tax, currency and health insurance specialists before his move. That's how I got a front-row seat to both sides of his journey.
A few things about his situation shape what you'll read, so I want to be upfront about them:
He and his wife hold European passports, so they skipped the visa process entirely. Most Americans won't. I've added the visa facts you'll need below.
They're not tax residents of either country. They split their year roughly into thirds between Spain, France and the US. That was a deliberate choice, and it keeps their taxes simpler than a full-time retiree's would be.
His wife is Spanish, so they had the language on their side in Spain. In France, both of them speak very little French.
Neither place is an expat hub. Near Pau and in San Sebastián, local professionals mostly deal with locals, not foreign buyers. As he put it, it isn't like the parts of the Mediterranean coast where everything is set up for foreigners.
So think of this as one honest, detailed experience, not a rule. Where his experience differs from what a typical American retiree would face, I say so.
France vs Spain at a glance
At a glance
France vs Spain for an American retiree
Based on my client's experience living in both, plus 2026 rules.
| Topic | France | Spain | Easier for him |
|---|---|---|---|
| Retiree visa (2026) | Visitor visa: about €1,478/month for one person | Non-lucrative visa: €2,400/month for one person | France |
| Registering | Started by the notaire at closing, then online | Town hall in person, plus a national registration | France |
| Buying property | State-appointed notaire, same process everywhere | Notario quality varies; you may need a lawyer too | France |
| Tax on US pensions and Social Security | Generally taxed only in the US (treaty) | Mostly taxed in Spain, with credit for US tax | France |
| Wealth tax | Real estate only, above €1.3M | Depends on the region; solidarity tax above €3M | France |
| Healthcare quality | Very good | Excellent, "as good or better than New York" | Spain |
| Day-to-day costs | Lower than the US; energy and appliances pricier | 20 to 30% below his New York life | Spain |
| Utilities and phone | English-speaking setup service; phone line a hassle | Straightforward via town hall and local providers | Tie |
| People and social life | "Absolutely floored" by how friendly people are | Easy to meet people, e.g. through tennis | Tie |
Income thresholds are 2026 figures and change yearly. Sources at the end of the article.
1. Visas and residency: France sets a lower income bar
My client didn't need a visa, but you almost certainly will if you plan to stay more than 90 days in any 180.
France: the long-stay visitor visa (VLS-TS visiteur). France has no visa called "retirement". Retirees use the visitor visa, a one-year renewable permit for people who live off their own income and don't work in France. In 2026, France lists minimum resources of about €1,478 net per month for one person. You'll also need health insurance for your stay.
Spain: the non-lucrative visa (NLV). Spain's equivalent asks you to prove €28,800 a year (€2,400 a month) for the main applicant, plus €7,200 a year for each family member. A couple therefore needs €36,000. You also need private Spanish health insurance with no co-payments.
What this means for you: France's income bar is roughly 40% lower than Spain's. For couples on a modest Social Security income, that alone can decide it.
Visa income requirement, 2026
France asks for about 40% less income
Minimum monthly income to qualify for a retiree-style visa, one person.
Spain adds €600/month (€7,200/year) for each family member, so a couple needs €3,000/month. Both visas also require health insurance.
His tip that applies to everyone: get your Spanish NIE (foreigner ID number) early, ideally at a Spanish consulate before you leave the US. "You just can't get anything done without it," he told me. Even the moving prep asked for it.
Visa help
Applying for the non-lucrative visa?
Our visa partners help you prepare your application and avoid the most common mistakes.
2. Registering with the authorities: France won, despite the language barrier
This was the biggest surprise of his whole move. "It should have been harder in France, because I don't really have much French," he said. "But it wasn't."
In Spain, it took two registrations, and he only knew about one. Like anyone living in Spain, they registered at the local town hall (the empadronamiento, or padrón). Appointments are usually required; they turned up very early one morning with their property documents and got it done. Their notary had told them that was all they needed.
It wasn't. Later, Spanish customs refused to release the belongings they'd shipped from the US until they also registered at national level. That's when they hit a catch-22: to book the appointment online you had to already be in the system, and you couldn't be in the system until you'd registered. They went in person, and a patient civil servant took their phone out to the street (the office Wi-Fi was too weak) and completed it for them.
Customs itself was a project: US tax records, 12 months of utility bills, and "it seemed like they asked for everything twice".
In France, the notaire started the process for them. At closing, the notaire sent the title to the French tax authority, which issued them a tax number some time after the sale. With that number, they registered online in minutes. France has no direct equivalent of Spain's padrón, so there was no second step.
Registering after buying a home
4 steps in Spain, 3 in France
What my client actually went through in each country.
Lesson for you: in Spain, ask early what registrations your situation needs beyond the padrón, especially if you're shipping belongings. A local gestor can save you weeks.
3. Buying property: the French notaire is more predictable
Both countries use notaries, but they play different roles, and that made a real difference for him.
In France, the notaire is a public official. "They're not your client, they're the state's client," he explained. "Yes, you pay them, but the interests they're really looking out for are the state's." Every notaire follows the same routine, so there's less pressure to find the perfect one.
From the first call, his notaire sent a standard letter in English laying out every step, from the initial contract to the final signing. He was buying some furniture with the house and wanted a specific issue written into the contract; both were handled clearly. "I knew from the first email exchange what the steps were going to be."
In Spain, he found more variation. "There's quite a difference between a good one and a not-so-good one," he said. One property he first looked at was historically protected and needed renovation. He wanted to know what he'd be allowed to do, but the notary wouldn't advise on that or put conditions in the contract. He'd have needed a separate lawyer. They walked away and bought elsewhere.
The final signing was professional, but some steps were unclear even at the end, such as whether the notary would file the title or whether they had to take it to the town hall themselves. "It was just a little bit less hand-holding," he said, and that was with fluent Spanish.
Lesson for you: in Spain, budget for an independent property lawyer as well as the notary, especially for older or protected buildings. In France, the notaire covers more of the process, but ask for their step-by-step letter in English up front.
4. Taxes: the biggest difference for most American retirees
When I asked my client what he'd tell a friend, taxes came first. "It's something I hadn't really thought about until I started to dig in," he said. "If I'd gone into that blindly, it could have been a real mess, and very, very costly." He ended up paying a Basque Country tax specialist for advice on his exact situation, and it was worth it.
France: a treaty built for American retirees. Under Article 18 of the US-France tax treaty, US Social Security and US pensions (including 401(k) and IRA withdrawals) are generally taxable only in the US. France still counts that income when setting your tax rate on any French income, but gives you a credit so the same dollars aren't taxed twice. France also recognizes Roth withdrawals as tax-free.
Spain: most retirement income is taxed in Spain. As a Spanish tax resident, you're taxed on worldwide income at progressive rates of roughly 19% to 47%, depending on the region. 401(k) and IRA withdrawals are taxed in Spain, with a credit on your US return. Social Security is a grey area: the treaty says the US "may" tax it, not that only the US can, and many advisors say Spain taxes it too, crediting the US tax.
Wealth tax: very different rules. France scrapped its general wealth tax in 2018. What remains, the IFI, applies only to real estate worth over €1.3 million. Spain taxes total net wealth, and the rules depend on your region. Madrid, Andalusia and four other regions give full relief to most residents, but a national solidarity tax applies above €3 million wherever you live. The Basque Country and Navarre run their own systems.
Property taxes. In France he pays two: the regular property tax (taxe foncière) and the second-home housing tax (taxe d'habitation). In Gipuzkoa, he told me the province dropped its second-home charge this year, so he now pays only the property tax there.
"There's just a lot more to consider in Spain when you're picking a spot to nest," he said. It's a bit like choosing between US states, on top of the federal system.
Tax for US retirees
How each country treats your US retirement income
For a full-time tax resident. My client is resident in neither, so get advice for your own case.
| Income or tax | France | Spain |
|---|---|---|
| US Social Security | Generally taxed only in the US | Grey area: many advisors say Spain taxes it too, with a credit for US tax |
| 401(k), IRA and US pensions | Generally taxed only in the US (Article 18) | Taxed in Spain, with a credit on your US return |
| How rates work | US income counts toward your rate on French income, with a credit | Progressive rates of roughly 19% to 47%, by region |
| Wealth tax | IFI on real estate only, above €1.3M | Set by region (some give full relief); national solidarity tax above €3M |
| Property taxes (his case) | Taxe foncière plus second-home taxe d'habitation | Property tax only in Gipuzkoa this year |
General information, not tax advice. Treaty treatment depends on your exact accounts and residency.
Lesson for you: run your numbers with a cross-border advisor before you choose a country, and before you choose a region in Spain. Join our monthly tax and finance masterclass to ask a Spanish tax lawyer and a US-Spain financial planner your questions live.
Tax and money
Run your numbers before you choose
Talk to a Spanish tax lawyer or a US-Spain financial planner about your Social Security, 401(k), IRA and pensions.
5. Healthcare: great care, cheaper cover, more paperwork than expected
The morning we spoke, he'd just had blood work done in San Sebastián after his annual check-up. His verdict on Spanish care: "as good or better than I had experienced in New York." His clinic has an app for booking and following appointments, available in six or seven languages, English included.
One policy for two countries. Because they live in both, they wanted a single international policy covering Spain and France. The big international insurers offer a worldwide plan (which includes the US and suits employer-paid expats) and a cheaper Europe-only plan. For retirees splitting time within Europe, the Europe-only plan made sense.
The frustration was the insurer, not the doctors. His provider required pre-approvals even for basics. "Somebody is asking you why you want an annual check-up visit, and how much you think it's going to cost," he said. "It's more like the old HMO process in the US." His wife, who knows the Spanish system well, found it a shock. Add hard-to-follow call center accents, and it became the one real irritation of their move.
But the price difference is huge. When he ran a small company in New York, health cover cost them about $40,000 a year per employee. His wife's employee-only share of a big employer's plan was double what they now pay for international insurance for both of them, before a high deductible.
If you'll be a full-time resident, you have public options too:
Spain: non-lucrative visa holders need private insurance at first. After one year of registered residence, you can buy into the public system through the convenio especial: €60 a month under 65, €157 a month at 65 and over (2026).
France: after three months of stable residence, you can generally join the public system (PUMa). Most retirees add a top-up policy, a mutuelle.
Public healthcare for residents
When can you join the public system?
Time from becoming a resident until you can join.
Lesson for you: compare how insurers handle claims and approvals, not just premiums and coverage. Ask how pre-authorization works for routine visits.
Health insurance
Get a visa-approved health insurance quote
Compare plans that meet visa rules, including options for pre-existing conditions. Quotes usually within 24 hours.
6. Cost of living: Spain edges it, but both beat the US
His overall view: living costs are "good in both places, and relatively comparable." Both regions are full of markets with excellent fresh meat, fish and vegetables.
Where France cost more for him:
Energy. Gas and electricity prices surprised him, though he's comparing an old, large, gas-heated country house with a recently renovated city apartment.
Appliances. A TV, kettle, toaster or washer-dryer tends to cost a little more in France than in northern Spain. He even briefly considered buying a tractor in Spain and bringing it over, before the idea struck him as ridiculous.
Gasoline, slightly.
"They're kind of just on the margin," he said. "It's not a world of difference."
Compared with New York, he estimates they spend 20 to 30% less on everyday basics, and probably closer to 30%. That's partly lifestyle: in New York they ate out or ordered in most nights, and now they have time to cook.
The wider data agrees that Spain is usually cheaper. Eurostat ranked France the 8th most expensive EU country by household spending and Spain 13th. Average property prices per square meter have also been about a third lower in Spain.
Cost of living
Both beat New York. Spain is usually cheaper
Rank source: Eurostat, via Connexion France. Savings figure is my client's own estimate.
Lesson for you: if you're buying an older French country home, get the energy performance rating and recent heating bills before you sign.
Currency transfers
Moving dollars to euros?
Bank fees and poor exchange rates can quietly cost thousands on a house purchase or monthly transfers. Our partner gets you a better rate.
7. Utilities, phone and internet: a draw, for different reasons
I spoke with him twice, a few weeks apart, and his take on this one shifted, which tells you a lot about how first impressions settle.
Spain. Right after the move, in August when everything runs slowly, he found setting up services more challenging than expected. By our second conversation, it looked simpler in hindsight: registering at the town hall got them onto water, sewage and rubbish collection, Wi-Fi was straightforward, and his wife got a Spanish phone number without trouble.
France. He found an English-speaking service for expats that signed them up for gas and electricity, which made it easy despite the language. Getting a French mobile number was more cumbersome. Internet was simple to order but needed a new connection to the old house.
Lesson for you: in France, look for English-language setup services offered by energy providers or expat agencies. And if you can, avoid landing in Spain or France in August, when many offices slow down or close.
8. Cars and getting around: he bought in Spain
He compared the cost of owning a car in each country, and Spain came out clearly cheaper, so he bought there. Buying was easy once he had his NIE and an address. The harder part was insurance: some insurers only cover a limited number of days outside the country you're insured in, which matters when you drive between two.
For year one, he used an English-speaking broker that works with insurers used to non-residents, and found it "really seamless". Long term, a family member who lives in Spain will own and insure the car, with him as a named driver, because it works out much cheaper.
As a non-resident, he drives on his US license. Full-time residents can't do that forever: in Spain, a US license is generally valid for six months after you become resident, and then you must pass the Spanish driving tests, as there's no exchange agreement with the US. France allows exchanges only for licenses from certain US states.
The border is "kind of invisible". He sometimes pops over to France to shop, and there's a train from San Sebastián towards Pau, finishing with a taxi to their village.
Lesson for you: if you'll drive across borders, ask insurers exactly how many days abroad they cover before you buy a policy.
9. Social life: friendlier than the stereotypes in both
Spain. His wife, who is Spanish, jokes that people in the Basque Country are harder to get to know. He hasn't found that at all. When he wanted to start playing tennis, he reached out and found partners with no trouble.
France. This was the happiest surprise. "We've been absolutely floored by how friendly and helpful everyone is," he said. "It's so contrary to the cartoon image of cranky, rude French people." Even with very little French, people are patient with them, and their nearest neighbor, a farmer, "couldn't be nicer, and very welcoming". Going to the market in Pau with a language barrier hasn't been a problem.
Lesson for you: a small-town or rural welcome can be warmer than you expect, but it still pays to learn the basics of the language. In both countries, a shared activity like tennis, walking or a class is the fastest way in.
So, France or Spain? Which fits your retirement
There's no single winner. Here's how I'd read his experience, and the 2026 rules, for different kinds of retirees.
Your shortcut
Which country fits your retirement?
| If you are... | Lean towards | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Living mainly on Social Security, a pension and IRA or 401(k) withdrawals | France | Treaty keeps most US retirement income taxed only in the US |
| On a modest income | France | Visitor visa needs about €1,478/month vs €2,400 for Spain's NLV |
| Holding significant savings or investments | Depends on region | Spanish wealth tax ranges from zero to significant; get advice first |
| Speaking Spanish but not French | Spain | Everyday life and in-person help are easier in a language you speak |
| Wanting the lowest day-to-day costs and lots of sunshine | Spain | Cheaper groceries, appliances and housing on average |
| Anxious about paperwork | France | More standardized property buying and registration, in his experience |
| Wanting both | Split your time | It worked for him, but residency and tax rules need expert planning |
His own setup mirrors the life they had in the US: a city apartment plus a country place two hours away. "It just happens that the place out in the country is in France," he said.
And the advice he'd give any friend? "Well in advance, arm yourself with information, because there are lots of little things that can trip you up and have large consequences."
FAQ: retiring in France vs Spain as an American
Is it cheaper to retire in France or Spain?
Spain is generally cheaper for day-to-day living and housing. My client found the gap small between rural southwest France and northern Spain, with energy and appliances the main extras in France.
Which country taxes American retirees less?
For most retirees living on US retirement income, France. The US-France treaty generally leaves Social Security, pensions and 401(k) or IRA withdrawals taxable only in the US. Spain taxes most of that income as a resident, with credits for US tax.
Does Spain have a wealth tax?
Yes, but it depends on the region. Six regions, including Madrid and Andalusia, give full relief to most residents, while a national solidarity tax applies above €3 million in net wealth.
Does France have a wealth tax?
Only on real estate. The IFI applies when your net property assets exceed €1.3 million.
How much income do I need for a retirement visa?
In 2026, about €1,478 a month for one person on France's long-stay visitor visa, and €2,400 a month for Spain's non-lucrative visa.
Is healthcare better in France or Spain?
Both rank among the world's best. My client rated Spanish care as good as or better than New York's. As a resident, you can join Spain's public system after one year through the convenio especial, or France's after three months through PUMa.
Can I live in both France and Spain?
Yes, and my client does. As EU citizens, he and his wife could. As a US-only passport holder, you'd be resident in one country and limited to visitor stays in the other, so plan residency and taxes carefully.
Planning your own move?
If Spain is on your shortlist, start where my client did: with the right information, early. Join our next monthly tax and finance masterclass or book a call with one of our vetted experts on taxes, currency transfers or health insurance.
Next step
Plan your move with a vetted expert
Tell us about your situation and we will connect you with the right expert for taxes, visas, health insurance or currency transfers.
About the author
Laetitia is the founder of Coming to Spain. She's French, has lived abroad for more than half her life (in Paris, London, the US and, since 2018, Barcelona), and has helped more than 100 Americans and Britons relocate to Spain. She works in English, French and Spanish.
This article is based on a client interview, shared with his permission and without his name, and checked against official and expert sources in November 2026. It's general information, not tax, legal or immigration advice. Rules and thresholds change every year, so confirm your own situation with a qualified advisor.
Sources
France long-stay visitor visa income, 2026: SmartAsset, Global Citizen Solutions
Spain non-lucrative visa income, 2026: Pellicer & Heredia, CostaLuz Lawyers
US-France treaty, Article 18: IRS technical explanation, Connexion France
US-Spain treaty and US retirement accounts: CostaLuz Lawyers, Greenback Tax Services
Spain wealth tax by region: Moving to Spain, PwC Tax Summaries
France real estate wealth tax (IFI): Service-Public.fr
Spain convenio especial: Spanish Ministry of Health, Greenback Tax Services
Cost of living and property prices: Connexion France